Few thrillers wear their silliness as proudly as Verity, and thankfully director Michael Showalter is in on the joke. Rather than treating every twist, sexual encounter and sinister revelation with deadly seriousness, the film embraces the pulpy excess of its material and turns it into a hugely entertaining psychological thriller that is sexy, campy, glossy and often a great deal of fun.
Based on the bestselling novel by Colleen Hoover, Verity is the latest film adaptation from an author whose books have become a publishing phenomenon. Hoover writes emotionally charged stories that frequently combine romance, complicated relationships, and sex. A lot of of sex.
Hoover built a following after self-publishing her debut novel Slammed in 2012, but her popularity exploded around 2020–21 when BookTok helped send titles such as It Ends with Us, Ugly Love and Verity back up the bestseller lists. Since then, her books have become increasingly attractive to Hollywood, with It Ends with Us starring Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni and Reminders of Him among the other novels to receive film adaptations.
The story follows Lowen Ashleigh (Dakota Johnson), a struggling writer who is offered the job of completing the hugely successful book series of Verity Crawford (Anne Hathaway) after Verity is left incapacitated following an mysterious accident. Lowen moves into the Crawford family home, where she begins researching Verity’s work and discovers a disturbing manuscript containing deeply personal revelations about the Crawfords.
Before long, Lowen can no longer tell what is real, what is fiction, and where genuine desire ends and manipulation begins. Josh Hartnett plays Jeremy Crawford, Verity’s husband, while Hathaway takes on the role of the author at the centre of the mystery.
What makes the film work as well as it does is that it never seems particularly embarrassed by its own excesses. There are moments when the story becomes so outrageous that you can almost feel the audience collectively rolling their eyes. Yet Showalter understands that this is precisely the appeal of this genre of stories.
It also does a surprisingly good job of adapting a novel built around first-person narration and considerable eroticism. Rather than simply attempting to reproduce the book’s internal voice, the film finds cinematic ways to communicate Lowen’s uncertainty and growing obsession. There are plenty of sex scenes, but they generally avoid becoming as salacious as the source material, allowing the thriller elements to take centre stage.
Dakota Johnson is excellent as Lowen, bringing just the right mixture of vulnerability, suspicion and likeability, while Anne Hathaway clearly understands exactly what kind of movie she is in and has a fantastic time playing Verity. Their performances give the material considerably more weight than it might otherwise deserve, while Josh Hartnett provides an appropriately ambiguous presence at the centre of the story.
Inevitably, Verity will be compared to The Housemaid, another glossy domestic thriller built on secrets, a suspicious household and a heroine who has taken on a job she probably shouldn’t have. But this is the sharper, better-made film. Showalter has a surer grip on tone than Paul Feig, balancing camp and menace without ever tipping into the absurd, and the performances are a clear step up.
Unfortunately, Verity stumbles at the final hurdle. The ultimate denouement feels rushed, and rather than delivering the satisfying payoff the increasingly bonkers story seems to promise, it comes across as an ending that has been hurried into place. After spending so much time building its mysteries, the film deserved a conclusion that felt more convincing and better earned.
That prevents Verity from becoming the great trashy thriller it occasionally threatens to be. Still, it is difficult not to enjoy a film this committed to its own particular brand of nonsense. It knows exactly who its audience is, gives them plenty of twists, glamour, sex and melodrama, and delivers some excellent performances along the way.
















