Nathan Silver, a director known for his character-driven stories and offbeat narratives, returns with Between the Temples, a comedy-drama that explores the intersection of faith, personal crisis, and unexpected connections.
Silver, who has previously directed films such as Thirst Street (2017) and The Great Pretender (2018), collaborates with co-writer C. Mason Wells to deliver a story that balances humour with poignant moments. The film boasts an impressive cast, including Jason Schwartzman (Rushmore, Marie Antoinette, Asteroid City), Carol Kane (Dog Day Afternoon, Annie Hall, The Princess Bride, Scrooged ) with Dolly de Leon, and Caroline Aaron, each bringing their unique talents to this masterfully executed and emotionally resonant tale.
The story centres on Ben Gottlieb, played by Jason Schwartzman, a synagogue cantor a who finds himself grappling with a crisis of faith. His life takes an unexpected turn when he is assigned to teach an adult bat mitzvah class, only to discover that one of his students is Carla O’Connor (Carol Kane), his former grade school music teacher. As Ben navigates this new dynamic, he must confront his own doubts and insecurities, while also helping Carla rediscover her own connection to faith.
Between the Temples is thematically rich, delving into the complexities of religious identity, the burden of expectation, and the quest for personal growth. Silver’s direction allows the film to oscillate between moments of light-hearted humour and deeper introspection, creating a tone that is both engaging and thought-provoking.
Silver manages to successfully weave these themes together, crafting a story that feels authentic and relatable, even as it delves into the often challenging topic of religious doubt.
Schwartzman delivers a nuanced portrayal of Ben Gottlieb. His ability to convey both the humour and pathos of his character’s journey makes him a compelling lead, grounding the film’s exploration of faith with a deeply human touch. Carol Kane, as Carla O’Connor, brings her signature charm and depth to the role, offering a performance that is both endearing and layered.
Elsewhere, Dolly de Leon and Caroline Aaron provide strong support as Ben’s lesbian mothers, adding further emotional weight to the story. Robert Smigel as Rabbi Bruce injects moments of levity, balancing the film’s more serious themes with his comedic timing.
This is a beautifully crafted film that showcases Silver’s talent for blending humour with profound thematic exploration. Whether you’re drawn to its comedic elements or its deeper reflections on spirituality, Between the Temples offers a rich and rewarding cinematic experience that lingers long after the credits roll.
