3. Amy Acker
First becoming a frequent collaborator at the end of Season 2 of Angel, Acker went on to star in Dollhouse, The Cabin in the Woods, and most recently as the female lead, Beatrice, in Much Ado About Nothing.
She has an unparalleled talent at playing quiet, introverted characters, and proved her versatility with her transformations into Illyria in Angel and Whiskey in Dollhouse, and like Dushku, she’d be perfect here on either side of the law.
