10. Gangs Of New York – Royal Rumble

It could be argued that Gangs of New York, while kick-starting a new collaboration phase for Scorsese (out with De Niro, in with DiCaprio), also happens to be the weakest of their collaborations. Gangs has plenty of ambition, plenty of scope and (in Daniel Day-Lewis) a towering central performance, but it is also a bit hit and miss on the performances side (Cameron Diaz is not terrible, but she is far from great) and lacking the focus that is required for such a sprawling saga. Having said that, we are addressing top scenes,  not top films and so this is in, potentially for a number of sequences, but specifically here for the opening battle of the Five Points, with the immigrant Irish squaring off against the “native-born” Americans.

It is, at times, brutal and unflinching, the bats, spikes, claws and blades doing their monstrous work on all and sundry and although the film has only just begun, the preparations of Liam Neeson’s Vallon and the grand-standing speech of Day-Lewis’s Bill the Butcher give context and resonance so that we care and so that it is all deemed to matter. Scorsese manages to capture and convey the chaos and indiscriminate carnage, without the scene losing coherence, something that many a supposedly accomplished action director would do well to consider.

[yframe url=’’]


If you liked this post you may also enjoy:

Previous articleSpidey & Electro Front 2 New Posters for The Amazing Spider-Man 2
Next articleSam Mendes & John Logan’s Penny Dreadful gets an Air Date and New Teaser
Dave has been writing for HeyUGuys since mid-2010 and has found them to be the most intelligent, friendly, erudite and insightful bunch of film fans you could hope to work with. He's gone from ham-fisted attempts at writing the news to interviewing Lawrence Bender, Renny Harlin and Julian Glover, to writing articles about things he loves that people have actually read. He has fairly broad tastes as far as films are concerned, though given the choice he's likely to go for Con Air over Battleship Potemkin most days. He's pretty sure that 2001: A Space Odyssey is the most overrated mess in cinematic history.